Elise W. Dees and Rigmor C. Baraas, "Performance of normal females and carriers of color-vision deficiencies on standard color-vision tests," J. Opt. Soc. Am. A 31, A401-A409 (2014)
Carriers of red–green color-vision deficiencies are generally thought to behave like normal trichromats, although it is known that they may make errors on Ishihara plates. The aim here was to compare the performance of carriers with that of normal females on seven standard color-vision tests, including Ishihara plates. One hundred and twenty-six normal females, 14 protan carriers, and 29 deutan carriers aged 9–66 years were included in the study. Generally, deutan carriers performed worse than protan carriers and normal females on six out of the seven tests. The difference in performance between carriers and normal females was independent of age, but the proportion of carriers that made errors on pseudo-isochromatic tests increased with age. It was the youngest carriers, however, who made the most errors. There was considerable variation in performance among individuals in each group of females. The results are discussed in relation to variability in the number of different L-cone pigments.
You do not have subscription access to this journal. Cited by links are available to subscribers only. You may subscribe either as an Optica member, or as an authorized user of your institution.
You do not have subscription access to this journal. Figure files are available to subscribers only. You may subscribe either as an Optica member, or as an authorized user of your institution.
You do not have subscription access to this journal. Article tables are available to subscribers only. You may subscribe either as an Optica member, or as an authorized user of your institution.
Results of male relatives not included.
Several girls made errors on Ishihara test; only three were confirmed as deutan carriers, whereas the other girls (number not specified) were only suspected to be carriers.
Carriers’ age not given.
Age based on seven of the carriers.
Only carrier’s age given.
The girls were classified as color deficient based on the same criteria as boys, but were suspected to be undetected carriers (family history was not collected).
AO HRR, 2nd edition.
Age range based on .
Age not given.
Table 2.
Age Demographics of Participants
Normal Females
Protan Carriers
Deutan Carriers
Age (Years)
#
Age ()
#
Age ()
#
Age ()
9–12
39
3
5
18–29
66
4
9
30–39
12
6
4
40–49
5
1
6
50–59
2
3
60–66
2
2
Total
126
14
29
Table 3.
Percentage of Participants Who Failed the PIC Tests Ishihara, HRR, or NTCV, for Normal Females (NT), Protan Carriers (PC), and Deutan Carriers (DC)
For the criteria for failing each test, see Section 3.A and Fig. 1.
Number of individuals is shown in parentheses.
Difference between groups is significant.
Table 4.
Rayleigh MMPs, MR, and Luminance Midpoint (LM); Medmont C-100 Null-Point Settings; and Square Root of Error Score (sqTES) on FM100-Hue Presented for Normal Females (NT), Protan Carriers (PC), and Deutan Carriers (DC)
Results of male relatives not included.
Several girls made errors on Ishihara test; only three were confirmed as deutan carriers, whereas the other girls (number not specified) were only suspected to be carriers.
Carriers’ age not given.
Age based on seven of the carriers.
Only carrier’s age given.
The girls were classified as color deficient based on the same criteria as boys, but were suspected to be undetected carriers (family history was not collected).
AO HRR, 2nd edition.
Age range based on .
Age not given.
Table 2.
Age Demographics of Participants
Normal Females
Protan Carriers
Deutan Carriers
Age (Years)
#
Age ()
#
Age ()
#
Age ()
9–12
39
3
5
18–29
66
4
9
30–39
12
6
4
40–49
5
1
6
50–59
2
3
60–66
2
2
Total
126
14
29
Table 3.
Percentage of Participants Who Failed the PIC Tests Ishihara, HRR, or NTCV, for Normal Females (NT), Protan Carriers (PC), and Deutan Carriers (DC)
For the criteria for failing each test, see Section 3.A and Fig. 1.
Number of individuals is shown in parentheses.
Difference between groups is significant.
Table 4.
Rayleigh MMPs, MR, and Luminance Midpoint (LM); Medmont C-100 Null-Point Settings; and Square Root of Error Score (sqTES) on FM100-Hue Presented for Normal Females (NT), Protan Carriers (PC), and Deutan Carriers (DC)