Abstract
We present some comments to the paper “Orthogonal basis with a conicoid first mode for shape specification of optical surfaces: comment.”
© 2016 Optical Society of America
1. Introduction
In page 5459 of reference [1], third line from bottom, the value c = 0.261082 obtained for the best-fit sphere curvature used in formula (42) is wrong. Consequently, the results presented in Figure 7 (page 5461) are wrong as well. In [2] we have introduced the correct value c = 0.964400103. With this correction, Fig. 7 of [1] should be replaced by Fig. 1. of [2].
In the discussion that Forbes included in his comment [3], he highlights several practical advantages of his Qb f s polynomials. In particular he emphasizes that the Qb f s polynomials operate by reference to the displacement along the normal to the best-fit sphere instead of the sag (z-displacement) that is the case considered in our approach. Another advantage of the Qb f s functions is avoiding the associated degeneracy of using a more general approach based on using best-fit conicoids instead of spheres. We agree that these features may have advantages for industrial applications. However, [1, 2] are a theoretical contribution in which we develop a rigorous method to obtain orthogonal systems where the first function q0 is a sphere or conicoid. The implementation of numerical examples is only illustrative for the sake of placing this work in the context of the current state of the art of this particular topic, whereas the main contribution is the theoretical framework proposed in that article.
Funding
Secretaría de Estado de Investigación, Desarrollo e Innovación (MTM2014-52859-P); Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (FIS2014-58303).
References and links
1. C. Ferreira, José L. López, R. Navarro, and E. Pérez-Sinusía, “Orthogonal basis with a conicoid first mode for shape specification of optical surfaces,” Opt. Express 24(5), 5448–5462 (2016). [CrossRef]
2. C. Ferreira, José L. López, R. Navarro, and E. Pérez-Sinusía, “Erratum on “Orthogonal basis with a conicoid first mode for shape specification of optical surfaces”,” Submitted.
3. G. W. Forbes, “Comment on “Orthogonal basis with a conicoid first mode for shape specification of optical surfaces”,” Opt. Express (in press).